| Mayor Joseph Wineland | 1907 to 1908 |
| Mayor Johnny Patton (Boy Mayor) | 1908 to 1948 |
| Mayor Ben Gapsewicz | 1948 to 1952 |
| Mayor Arthur J. Blackburn | 1952 to 1960 |
| Mayor Lawrence Carr | 1960 to 1964 |
| Mayor Arthur J. Blackburn | 1965 to 1969 |
| Mayor Eldreth (Rocky) Rundlett | 1969 to 1994 |
| Mayor Ronald (Red) Danewicz | 1994 to 2004 |
| Mayor Elward B. Verrett, Sr. | 2004 to 2005 |
| Mayor Robert E. Polk | 2005 to present |
